From the monthly archives:

January 2010

MBE Question of the Day #33

by Maryann Herman

Jan
31

In response to a number of accidents involving pedestrians in the local business district, City enacted a statute making it illegal for a pedestrian to walk through the City’s central business district anywhere other than on the sidewalk. City also enacted a statute making it illegal for any business to obstruct the sidewalk in front of its establishment. Turner was walking along the sidewalk in the central business district on his way to lunch. Turner discovered that Loader had stacked a pile of boxes in front of his establishment, in such a way that it totally obstructed the sidewalk. Turner stepped into the street to walk around the obstruction of boxes. While in the street, Turner was struck by a taxi cab, negligently driven by Cabbie.

If Turner asserts a claim against Cabbie, Turner’s act of leaving the sidewalk and walking into the street will have which of the following effects?

A.  It will bar Turner’s recovery as a matter of law.

B.  It will bar Turner’s recovery unless Cabbie saw Turner in time to avoid the impact.

C.  It may be considered by the trier of fact on the issue of Cabbie’s liability.

D.  It is not relevant in determining the rights of Turner.

{ 8 comments }

MBE Question of the Day #32

by Maryann Herman

Jan
30

A high school principal was alerted by police that there was a substantial amount of crack cocaine being sold and used at the school. He therefore ordered that every candidate for a sports team at the school submit to a drug test before becoming eligible to play, and ordered random searches of student lockers at the school.

A basketball star, who had no record of drug use or possession, declined to take a drug test and brought suit to compel the school to permit him to play on the basketball team. The trial court denied relief, and the basketball star appealed.

When the school officials made a random search of the school lockers, they found small quantities of crack cocaine in the locker of a student, and he was charged with unlawful possession of the substance. The student made a motion to suppress the evidence of crack cocaine. The trial court denied the motion. The student was subsequently convicted and appealed.

The appellate court should decide in favor of:

A.  The basketball star, but not the student.

B.  The student, but not the basketball star.

C.  Both the student and the basketball star.

D.  Neither the student, nor the basketball star.

{ 11 comments }

MBE Question of the Day #31

by Maryann Herman

Jan
29

A mother, the owner of the family homestead, planned to retire to a warmer climate. She had two children, a daughter and a son. The mother executed a deed of the homestead and delivered it to her daughter. In addition to a description of the property, the deed contained the following language: “Grantee, by acceptance of this deed, agrees to provide a bedroom in the property known as the family homestead for the use of my son during his lifetime.” The mother died soon after moving, leaving her entire estate to her daughter and son in equal shares. The son, upset by his mother’s death, sank deep into alcoholism. The daughter, unwilling to tolerate the son’s behavior, prohibited him from entering the homestead.

The son then brought a suit against the daughter to establish a one-half interest in the homestead.

In that lawsuit,

A.  The son will prevail, because the daughter breached her contractual obligation to him.

B.  The son will prevail, because the condition in the deed to the daughter was broken.

C.  The daughter will prevail, because the mother retained no interest in the homestead.

D.  The daughter will prevail, because the son’s conduct terminated the rights he had to an interest in the homestead.

{ 9 comments }

MBE Question of the Day #30

If a criminal defendant takes the stand on her own behalf, which of the following convictions is inadmissible to impeach her credibility even though the trial judge believes that the probative value of the evidence outweighs its prejudicial effect?
 A.  A conviction more than fifteen years old where the prosecution has notified the defendant of its [...]

Read the full article →

MBE Question of the Day #29

A truck driver was buying gas at a gas station when a car entered the station. The truck driver observed the occupant of the car, who had only one arm, pay a large number of one hundred dollar bills to the attendant and pick up a brief case. When the brief case was open for [...]

Read the full article →

MBE Question of the Day #28

A homeowner and a carpenter entered into a contract under which the carpenter agreed to construct a garage on the homeowner’s property and also to repair the roof of the homeowner’s house. When the carpenter had finished two-thirds of the work to construct the garage and one-fourth of the work to repair the roof, a [...]

Read the full article →

MBE Question of the Day #27

A state is operating a nuclear power plant on a river. The plant uses river water for cooling and discharges water back into the river 10 degrees warmer than when it was taken in. While the discharged water quickly cools, it has adversely affected the business of a downstream ice cutting operator, located in a [...]

Read the full article →

MBE Question of the Day #26

A champion swimmer is sitting next to a swimming pool at a hotel.  A child is playing in the pool and splashes the swimmer, annoying him. The child then trips, and is unable to regain her balance. The swimmer watches while the child drowns. The swimmer is charged with manslaughter.
He will most likely be found:
A.  Guilty [...]

Read the full article →

MBE Question of the Day #25

Walter, a 16-year-old, purchased an educational chemistry set manufactured by Chemco, Walter invited his friend and classmate, Peter, to assist him in a chemistry project. Referring to a library chemistry book on explosives and finding that the chemistry set contained all of the necessary chemicals, Walter and Peter agreed to make a bomb. During the [...]

Read the full article →

MBE Question of the Day #24

A man owned an authentic red 1954 Corvette. Because the paint on the car was badly chipped and discolored, he brought it to a restorer, whose principal business was the restoration of antique Corvettes. The man asked the restorer to paint the car with the standard paint used on 1994 Chevrolets, a paint which was [...]

Read the full article →